I've come to realize you can not think too highly nor too lowly of yourself as a homeschool mom. Some kids, because of their own natural curiosity and good humor, will suck up every last crumb of your teaching and others vomit most of it out. The difference is about 200 points on the PSAT as far as my kids are concerned.
It is frustratingly hard to tell if you are doing a good job homeschooling. We labor with no pay and no clear results for years. We try to evaluate based on the child's response or his scores, but the cause/effect relationship is murky.
I can not take credit for a hungry learner nor for the one who "hates this book". Neither are poor comments, "This is stupid!" my fault nor is the 99% reading and writing percentage on their PSAT my win. So much depends on the child. I have not necessarily taught badly, uninterestingly or un-intuitively. Maybe I have, maybe I haven't. They may be influenced positively or negatively by my personality, style, methods, curriculum, but at end of the day, their internal disposition weighs heavy on their education.
I believe that a negative disposition reveals something about their gift mix. My children have a strong bent towards learning a certain way and along certain lines. Though no one has loved Algebra, they all have loved something. Abi loves cosmetology, Thomas loves build to learn, Aziza loves chatting with people, and Bethan loves Most Things. This means they may hate things that they need to learn--that they need to know to develop good judgement as humans. This means they will fight me to stay ignorant on the things that don't interest them. I stay in tension with them on these topics fighting to find the way to their heart, to their reason. Like feeding peas to threes.
At the end of the day, you graduate your child and have no idea what just happened. You don't know what went in, what will be forgotten carelessly or intentionally. You threw the seeds at the dirt, nurtured some plants and hope to God the weeds will die and the plants will take strong root in good ground. This is tough work. You can't take credit for it, yet you have given everything for it. You don't get a paycheck to prove you did something worthwhile, but you cling to the hope of the Word of God and the vision of your future generations, "Your children will be taught of the Lord and great will be your children's peace." (Isaiah 54)





